16 Popes: Château Pape Clément 2006–1947

Posted by Stuart George in Tastings | Leave a comment

On 6 July, my friend Linden Wilkie very generously invited me to his tasting of 16 vintages of Château Pape Clément, spanning 2006 to 1947.

I have been to Pape Clément only once but I have met its owner Bernard Magrez several times. I was seated next to him at a lunch that he hosted at Alain Ducasse’s restaurant at The Dorchester a couple of years ago. There was a remarkably high turnout for that tasting and lunch by my wine writing colleagues!

Linden’s tasting showed how M Magrez has pursued a modern, extracted style of wine in recent years. The 2006, 2005 and 2003 vintages were rather oak-dry to my palate, though doubtless this style appeals to many people. The 2000 was oxidised, which is unacceptable at this level.

The ’98 was excellent, as was a La Mission Haut-Brion tasted in Hong Kong recently. These two prove how Graves vintages often follow the Right Bank in exceptional years.

I preferred the verve and flow of the 1996 over the more sullen 1995. The “decadent” 1990 was a popular choice by my fellow tasters but I found it too wayward and dirty – a very impertinent 20-year old.

The 1971 smelled like old claret from an indifferent vintage – which is to say, not particularly appealing. The 1961 was very good, though as is often the case – Haut-Bailly, for example – it captured the richness of the vintage rather than the estate’s terroir.

A magnum of the 1950 was awful, fractured and decrepit. A pity.

The 1947, however, was a lovely old wine, still articulate but so tertiary that it was unrecognisable as Pape Clément. Like the 1961, it was representative of its ripe, rich vintage. Drink up.

Share This Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *